PolitiKool
Discourse from America’s online town square
Saturday, November 21, 2026

Bill Maher Warns Democrats Not to Revive 'Defund the Police' After Midterm Wins

The Real Time host devoted roughly half of his closing New Rules to Republican cruelty, then turned on his own side's lawn signs.

Bill Maher
Illustration: PolitiKool (AI-assisted) (PolitiKool illustration)

Bill Maher warned Democrats on Friday not to read their midterm sweep as permission to go back to ideas like defunding the police. He told them the movement "only made life worse for the people who mostly want more cops."

The warning closed Friday's Real Time with Bill Maher on HBO. Roughly half the segment blamed Republicans' losses on what Maher called a turn to cruelty under President Donald Trump. But the comedian, who has long criticized the left, saved his last word for the party that just won.

"Now that Democrats won the election, let's not get high on our own supply like the last crowd did and interpret the 'W' as a sign to go back to bad ideas," Maher said. "Bad ideas like defund the police, which only made life worse for the people who mostly want more cops."

Bill Maher Blames Republican 'Cruelty' for Midterm Losses

Maher did not defend Trump. In the final rule, he said "As much as anything, Republicans lost this election because no one wanted the pendulum to swing all the way to full asshole, to cruelty." Then he listed examples, from Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to Kristi Noem's tenure at the Department of Homeland Security.

"The opposite of being a sanctimonious prick isn't being an actual prick," he said.

The losses were broad. In the Senate, Democrats hold 55 seats to the GOP's 44, with a net gain of eight, NBC News results show. That matches the count Maher gave in his opening monologue. Alaska remains uncalled with 97.4 percent of the vote reported, and Democrat Mary Peltola leads Republican Senator Dan Sullivan 49.9 percent to 46.0 percent there.

The party won without being popular. PolitiKool's polling average puts Democratic favorability at 39.2 percent, with 58.1 percent unfavorable.

Maher Turns on Democrats' 'Lawn Sign People'

He argued that Trump's 2024 win was partly a reaction to "what I call the lawn sign people."

He went through other policies too: lax enforcement of shoplifting laws, clean-needle programs, and dropping standardized tests.

He ended with Seattle. He was referring to the Capitol Hill Occupied Protest zone, known as CHOP, which demonstrators set up after the murder of George Floyd. The city cleared it on July 1, 2020, after two teenagers were killed and three people seriously wounded in late-night shootings there since June 8, PBS NewsHour reported.

What Polling Shows on Police Presence

Polling shows most Black Americans wanted police to stay in their neighborhoods, though few asked for more of them. A Gallup survey taken June 23 to July 6, 2020, weeks after George Floyd's murder, found 81 percent of Black Americans wanted police to spend the same amount of time or more in their area. Sixty-one percent said the same amount, 20 percent said more and 19 percent said less.

Most Americans wanted police presence kept or increased in 2020
All U.S. adults
86%
White Americans
88%
Hispanic Americans
83%
Black Americans
81%
Asian Americans
72%

Share who wanted police to spend the same amount of time or more in their area; Gallup Panel survey conducted June 23-July 6, 2020.

Source: Gallup

A separate Pew Research Center survey, which asked about police spending rather than police time, found support for cuts falling. The share of Black adults who wanted police spending in their area reduced fell from 42 percent in June 2020 to 23 percent in September 2021. Among all adults, the share who wanted spending increased rose from 31 percent to 47 percent over the same period.

Cities That Cut Police Budgets, Then Restored Them

Several major cities that cut police budgets in 2020, including Los Angeles, Austin and New York, increased them again within a year, NBC News reported. Los Angeles cut $150 million from the LAPD in 2020, and the next spring the mayor proposed raising its budget to $1.76 billion. Austin reversed its own $150 million cut. The reversals also reflected staffing shortages, a state law penalizing Austin's cut and rising violent crime, the report said, and experts caution against attributing crime to budget cuts. Baltimore cut $22 million in a move led by Brandon Scott, then a city councilman, and in 2021 Scott, by then mayor, proposed a $555 million police budget, $28 million more than the year before. New York City added $200 million in its fiscal 2022 budget.

"I don't care what race or class you are, when you dial emergency services, you want to hear '911, what's your emergency?'" Maher said.

Maher said next week's episode is the last of the season.

Sources

2 more sources