PolitiKool
Discourse from America’s online town square
Saturday, November 21, 2026

Brian Kilmeade Warns GOP Will Lose 2028 Without Hispanic Voters

After Donald Trump said his deportation policy "might be too tough," the Fox News host said the party's Hispanic support had fallen from 45 percent to 30.

Brian Kilmeade
Illustration: PolitiKool (AI-assisted) (PolitiKool illustration)

On Tuesday, Fox News host Brian Kilmeade warned Republicans that they will lose again in 2028 unless they win back the Hispanic voters he says the Trump administration's deportation crackdown drove away.

Kilmeade was speaking on The Brian Kilmeade Show two days after President Donald Trump told 60 Minutes that his deportation policy "might be too tough." Kilmeade said Republicans' share of the Hispanic vote had dropped "from 45% to 30%." He did not give a source for the figure on air.

"And they misinterpreted whether you think it's right or not, 45 to 30, if they don't find a way to get those votes back without pandering, they're not gonna have any more success in 28 than they did in 26," Kilmeade said.

The warning comes a week after Democrats won both chambers of Congress in the midterms. Trump's approval rating stands at 38.1 percent in PolitiKool's polling average.

What Trump Told 60 Minutes About Deportations

In the interview with Ross Douthat, which aired Sunday, Trump said immigration "both helped and hurt" his party. "I think I got an A+ for closing up the border," he said. When Douthat asked whether his deportation policy went too far, Trump replied, "I think it might be too tough, yeah," according to the CBS News transcript.

Trump also suggested a deal for some long-term residents: "let the people that are here, and in some cases here for ten and 15 years, work a deal for them." In a separate clip that Kilmeade played, the president ruled out amnesty and said, "my policy hasn't changed." Kilmeade took that to mean "maybe there's an extended work visa, but it's not the word amnesty."

Kilmeade Defends the Border Work and Blames the Visuals

Kilmeade's complaint was about politics, not the policy itself. He said "sealing the border was certainly effective" and that "we virtually stopped illegal immigration, the president's policies have." In his view, the problem was the optics.

"The president needs to do some photo ops down there and go to some empty centers. It used to be packed with people and would have helped," he said. "I have never even seen the president this term go to the border."

She said the way the operation was carried out "visually was very repelling, I think, to a lot of people," and added that "people don't wanna see grandma being carted off."

Kilmeade agreed: "Yes, don't publicize that. Because whether you like it or not, most of the people deported are Hispanics, because most of them coming through illegally are Hispanic."

What the Exit Polls Show on Hispanic Voters

The exit polls match Kilmeade's starting figure, but the decline they show is smaller than his. Trump won 45 percent of Latino voters in 2024, up from 32 percent in 2020, NBC Washington reported. In last week's midterms, NBC's exit poll found Latino voters backed Democrats 64 percent to 34 percent for Republicans.

The AP Voter Poll points the same way. It found "only about one-third" of Hispanic voters backed the Republican in their House race, compared with roughly 4 in 10 who voted for Trump two years earlier. Pew Research Center's validated-voter study put Trump's 2024 Hispanic share higher, at 48 percent, up from 36 percent in 2020.

Republican share of the Latino vote
2020 (Trump)
32%
2024 (Trump)
45%
2026 (Republican)
34%

The 2020 and 2024 figures are Trump's presidential share as reported by NBC Washington. The 2026 figure is the Republican share among Latino voters in NBC's 2026 midterm exit poll. All are exit-poll estimates, not certified results.

Source: NBC Washington; NBC News

NBC's exit poll also found that 58 percent of midterm voters said the administration's immigration enforcement had gone too far. Twenty percent said it had not gone far enough, and 22 percent called it about right.

Downey's Obama Comparison

She was referring to roughly the first 18 months of Trump's second term.

Under Barack Obama, whom immigrant advocates nicknamed "deporter in chief," formal removals reached a record 438,421 in fiscal 2013, Pew Research Center reported. Downey did not name the tracker behind her comparison. Pew's 438,421 is a single-year figure for formal removals at Obama's peak, so it cannot be compared directly with the first 18 months of Trump's second term.

What Happens Next

An hour after the interview, which was taped at the White House on Friday, Trump named Stephen Miller White House chief of staff, according to the CBS News transcript. Kilmeade defended the hire in a simulcast segment with Fox Business host Stuart Varney.

Trump told Douthat that "people have already called me" about a deal. It is not yet clear whether any deal would be enough to bring back the voters Kilmeade says the party lost.

Sources

3 more sources