Jessica Tarlov Warns Democrats Against 'Revenge Tour' on Trump Cabinet
The Fox News co-host said Robert Garcia's 'Lawyer up' post plays into what she called one of the GOP's most potent attack lines.

Jessica Tarlov, co-host of the Raging Moderates podcast and of Fox News' The Five, warned Democrats on Tuesday that the accountability push from their incoming House majority could hand Republicans their best argument against the party.
Tarlov was speaking with her co-host, NYU Stern professor Scott Galloway, as House Republicans moved to protect Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth from impeachment. She said talk of prosecutions plays into the GOP's "lawfare" charge and could crowd out the affordability agenda that carried Democrats to their wins on Nov. 3.
"But you got to be really careful about this because I do think it is one of their most potent attack lines against Democrats using this lawfare argument," Tarlov said.
Neither host argued against impeaching Hegseth. Galloway said voters were "looking for a blood offering" and called Hegseth's impeachment "the blood offering that every Democrat wants, the voters want, and even some Republicans want." What they questioned was proportion: how much of the new majority's time accountability should take up.
Tarlov Says Robert Garcia's 'Lawyer Up' Feeds the GOP
Tarlov singled out Representative Robert Garcia of California, the incoming chair of the House Oversight Committee, who urged officials to "lawyer up" in an online post that, Tarlov said, went out on election night as the results came in. Garcia has also asked what Todd Blanche is afraid of over Blanche not appearing before the Oversight Committee.
"And the title of his talk was Lawyer Up, which is what he tweeted out in the middle of the results coming in on Tuesday night," Tarlov said. People who hear that, she said, ask, "is this just going to be a revenge tour, like you said, right?" She was referring to Galloway, who had asked minutes earlier, "when does the accountability tour turn into the revenge tour, or is this what the public wants?"
"And the base loved it, right? That's what they want to hear," Tarlov said. But she said Hakeem Jeffries, who is in line to become speaker, "has to be very careful in how he treads these lines, because he's gotten an agenda to get through and his agenda is driven by affordability concerns. It's not driven by whatever is going to happen to Pete Hegseth and RFK Jr. and Elon Musk and the Trump kids, et cetera."
She also called "government corruption, a huge issue to people," and said voters want accountability "not for made up crimes, but for what they've actually done to the government."
Republicans Block First Hegseth Impeachment Vote
On Tuesday, the House voted 211-204 to send Massie's resolution to committee, which kills it for now. Representative Thomas Massie, an outgoing Kentucky Republican, had filed eight articles of impeachment. Democrats can bring the effort back when the new Congress convenes on Jan. 3. Some Democrats had already backed the articles.
The polling supports only part of Galloway's claim that Hegseth is unpopular with Republicans. A Pew Research Center survey taken Jan. 20-26 found that 41 percent of Americans viewed him unfavorably and 26 percent favorably. Republicans and Republican-leaning independents, however, rated him favorably 52 percent to 14 percent. In the same survey, 74 percent of that group viewed Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. favorably.
Galloway said calls to impeach Kennedy picked up after Annie Andrews, South Carolina's Democratic senator-elect, and Senator Bernie Sanders voiced support. Tarlov called Kennedy "a total crank for an HHS secretary" and said, "maybe it's time to do something about it."
Alexander Vindman's Primary Loss as a Warning
Galloway offered Alexander Vindman as a warning. Vindman, the former Army officer whose testimony was central to Donald Trump's first impeachment, lost Florida's Aug. 18 Democratic Senate primary to state Representative Angie Nixon, a democratic socialist. He had raised about $16 million, while Nixon raised just under $1 million.
"People basically described his campaign as a failed attempt to have an impeachment nostalgia tour," Galloway said.
"I don't think the Democrats are gonna be able to keep these swing voters if they just go on what's called, for lack of a better term, an accountability slash revenge tour," he added. He said he wanted to see Democrats push "universal healthcare raising minimum wage, housing credits, whatever it is."
What Voters Said Drove Their Midterm Votes
The exit polls back the hosts' focus on prices. In ABC News' preliminary voter poll, about 4 in 10 House voters named the economy as their most important issue, and about a third named the state of democracy. In the CNBC Voter Poll, nearly 9 in 10 voters called the cost of living a crucial or major factor in their vote for Congress. Trump's approval on the economy stands at 29.7 percent in PolitiKool's polling average.
The last Democratic House majority also legislated on prices. On Dec. 12, 2019, Speaker Nancy Pelosi's House passed its drug-pricing bill, H.R. 3.
What Happens Next
When Democrats take the gavel in January, they can bring back Massie's articles, write their own against Kennedy, or open Garcia's investigations. Each one will compete for floor time with the wage and health care bills that Galloway and Tarlov want at the front of the line.
Sources
- House shelves Hegseth impeachment resolution (NBC News live blog) — 211-204 vote to refer Massie's impeachment resolution to committee
- House Republicans Block Hegseth Impeachment, but Democrats Could Revive Effort in 2027 (TIME) — Democrats can revive the effort when the new Congress convenes Jan. 3
- How Americans view key members of the Trump administration (Pew Research Center) — Hegseth and Kennedy favorability overall and among Republicans, Jan. 20-26, 2026
5 more sources
- Rep. Robert Garcia outlines investigative priorities as next House Oversight chair (Fox LA) — Garcia as incoming Oversight chair; his 'lawyer up' online post
- Democratic socialist Angie Nixon won Tuesday's primary in Florida (WUSF) — Vindman's primary loss and the fundraising gap
- Preliminary voter poll on House voters' top issues (ABC7/ABC News) — About 4 in 10 named the economy as their top issue; about a third named democracy
- 2026 midterms: Economy, Iran war hit Trump and GOP (CNBC) — Nearly 9 in 10 called the cost of living a crucial or major factor in their vote
- How the House prescription drug plan would try to lower drug prices (WITF) — H.R. 3 passed the House on Dec. 12, 2019