PolitiKool
Discourse from America’s online town square
Saturday, November 21, 2026

Megyn Kelly Says GOP Hawks Seem to Have Turned Donald Trump on JD Vance

The SiriusXM host pointed to Mark Levin and said the aim is to keep Vance from the 2028 nomination, as a new Emerson poll shows Marco Rubio ahead.

Megyn Kelly, JD Vance, Donald Trump
Illustration: PolitiKool (AI-assisted) (PolitiKool illustration)

Megyn Kelly says it seems Republican hawks have convinced President Donald Trump that Vice President JD Vance betrayed him when he blamed the Iran war for the GOP's midterm losses. She also says the campaign is meant to sink Vance's chances of winning the 2028 nomination.

Kelly, who describes herself as a right-leaning independent, made the argument on Thursday's episode of The Megyn Kelly Show. A day earlier, The New York Times reported that Trump had grown frustrated with how his vice president explained the losses.

Kelly played a montage of conservative commentators criticizing Vance. "The knives are out for JD Vance," she said when it ended, before asking whether their campaign would work. She then described the Times report and presented its influence on Trump as her own read of events.

"To me it seems that that cast of commentators I just played for you has gotten to him," Kelly said. "He's very close with Mark Levin. I'm sure he's listening to him, and they appear to have convinced him that it was an act of betrayal for JD Vance to say what he said."

Kelly did not cite any reporting that Levin had talked with Trump about Vance.

What Vance Said After the Midterms

On November 4, the day after Democrats won control of both chambers of Congress, Vance wrote in a social media post that "the real reason we lost is obvious to almost everyone." He added, "If you'd like to argue it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next 6 years was worth it, then do so." Al Jazeera reported that Vance, citing a pollster, said ending the Iran war and "changing our relationship with Israel" were two of the top four answers from Trump 2024 voters who planned to vote Democratic in the midterms.

At first, Trump took it in stride. He called Vance's comments "largely true" and said he would have done nothing differently.

The Times reported, according to people with knowledge of the president's comments, that Trump has since complained privately that Vance should have said going to war was the right call.

Kelly said the commentators had also convinced Trump "that there wasn't enough praise of dear leader in the criticism so that JD Vance can be hung out to dry." She called Vance "the member of the president's inner circle who's been the most against this thing" and said the effort is meant "to make damn sure JD does not have a running chance at becoming the GOP nominee."

Her guest, evolutionary biologist Bret Weinstein, said Vance was "damned if he does and damned if he doesn't." Weinstein added that he found Vance's statement "frankly too mild."

Does Vance's Explanation Hold Up?

The AP Voter Poll, a survey of more than 100,000 voters, partly supports Vance. About 6 in 10 voters said the U.S. made the "wrong decision" in taking military action against Iran. But only about one-third called the war "crucial" to their vote for Congress, compared with roughly half who said that about the cost of living or government corruption.

Trump's approval stands at 37.5 percent, with 59.3 percent disapproving, in PolitiKool's polling average. In an Emerson College poll conducted November 14-16, 49 percent of voters said ending the war in Iran should be a top priority for Congress next year. That tied it for second with banning stock trading by members of Congress, behind the cost of living at 57 percent.

Rubio Gains on Vance in 2028 Polling

Kelly said Kalshi, a prediction market that sponsors her show, puts Vance's chance of running in 2028 at 71 percent, down from 87 percent in September. She said Rubio's chance of running had risen to 65 percent from 47 percent. On Tuesday, CNBC reported Kalshi's figure for a Vance run at 73 percent. Vance said this week that he will decide "sometime next year."

Kelly also cited Emerson's poll, saying that when voters were asked open-ended who they would like to see as the nominee, 36 percent named Rubio and 20 percent named Vance. Emerson's results page shows Rubio leading 44 percent to 24 percent when respondents chose from a list. Vance leads the GOP field in PolitiKool's 2028 Republican primary average, at 38.9 percent to Rubio's 16.3 percent.

Rubio Leads Vance in Emerson's 2028 Republican Poll
Rubio, open-ended
36%
Vance, open-ended
20%
Rubio, from list
44%
Vance, from list
24%

Emerson College national poll conducted November 14-16, 2026; 'open-ended' means respondents named a preferred Republican nominee without a list.

Source: Emerson College Polling

What Happens Next

Kelly says hawks are pushing to restart the war, while Trump is publicly saying he wants to give diplomacy a try. If Trump escalates, Vance will again have to choose between loyalty to the president and the position he took after the midterms.

Sources

3 more sources