PolitiKool
Discourse from America’s online town square
Saturday, November 21, 2026
Latest News · MS NOW · November 20, 2026

Did a Florida judge ‘misconstrue’ Supreme Court precedent in Trump’s favor?

Latest News MS NOW POLITIKOOL · LATEST NEWS

A federal judge in Tampa has let Donald Trump's defamation suit against The New York Times and Penguin Random House go forward in part, though most of what he challenged was thrown out. U. S. District Judge Steven Merryday left seven statements in play. The suit targets a book by Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner, plus articles by them and by Peter Baker, which Trump says damaged a reputation he built as a private citizen and businessman, according to MS NOW.

The defendants had urged dismissal because Trump, as a public figure, had not shown actual malice under New York Times v. Sullivan. Merryday agreed the case is governed by that precedent but found it plausible that the writers knew they needed a formal legal opinion and never got one. He called the experts they consulted superficial, even though one described the conduct as highly suspicious and another said it smelled like a crime. Among the surviving claims are assertions about money Trump received from his father and about scrutiny of his ties to the Mafia.

The decision is preliminary and does not decide who wins.

Summarized by PolitiKool from MS NOW’s reporting. Read the full story at MS NOW →