PolitiKool
Discourse from America’s online town square
Saturday, November 21, 2026

Former Obama Speechwriter Jon Lovett Faults Chris Van Hollen's Leader Bid

Lovett said the Maryland senator never explained how past shutdown fights would have gone differently under him.

Jon Lovett, Chris Van Hollen, Chuck Schumer
Illustration: PolitiKool (AI-assisted) (PolitiKool illustration)

Jon Lovett, a former Obama speechwriter and co-host of Pod Save America, said that Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen "didn't really answer" the central question of his challenge to Chuck Schumer: what he would have done differently as the Senate Democrats' leader.

The question matters now. Democrats netted at least eight Senate seats in the election, with one race still uncalled, and Van Hollen announced last Thursday that he would challenge Schumer, who has led the caucus for close to a decade, in a secret-ballot vote expected next month. Schumer has said, "I have the votes to continue serving as Democratic Leader."

Lovett's criticism came right after his co-host Tommy Vietor interviewed Van Hollen for the episode.

"You asked him point blank, like what are the specific ways you would have done things differently than Chuck Schumer?" Lovett said. "He didn't really answer that question, which I think is just really disappointing."

Jon Lovett Is Not Backing Chuck Schumer

Lovett did not endorse Schumer. He said he could not tell whether Van Hollen was keeping his answers for the senators who will actually vote, and he closed his critique by noting, "I'm not a voter in this election, so I leave it up to them."

His co-hosts made the same point. Vietor said the job is "very hard to campaign for" because a leader reflects the caucus, not their own agenda. Jon Favreau, a former Obama speechwriter who co-hosts the show, said leaders "have less power than I think it might seem from the outside" and said Van Hollen's best case, to him, is "we need a new face and a new voice, and Schumer has had his chance," though how that would play out "is unclear."

Lovett also offered a warning that applies to any challenger: "you either lose a Van Hollen, or you live long enough to become a Schumer, right?"

Shutdown Fights at the Center of Lovett's Question

Lovett said Schumer's best case is his record as majority leader. "He got a bunch of stuff through the Senate when he was the majority leader," Lovett said. "Like he got a lot through, including with Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema." He noted that Democrats are "two years away from the possibility of a Democratic president and a Democratic Senate."

The complaints about Schumer, Lovett said, come from his time as minority leader. He pointed to the health-care shutdown, when some Democrats broke ranks and reopened the government. On November 9, 2025, eight members of the Democratic caucus voted with Republicans to advance that reopening bill. It did not extend the Affordable Care Act subsidies Democrats had shut the government down over. It got only a promise from Majority Leader John Thune to hold a vote on them in December.

"Would previous shutdowns have ended differently with Van Hollen, he doesn't really say, like what did Schumer do wrong in the past, he doesn't really say," Lovett said. "I would like him to really lay out those differences, but he kind of was reluctant."

What Chris Van Hollen Did and Did Not Commit To

Van Hollen did draw some lines in the interview. On the Iran war, he said, "I don't see how we can vote to spend ... one penny more to keep this illegal war going." He said a leader should not be "jumping into a heavily contested Senate primary like we witnessed in Michigan and Minnesota." He also said the caucus wants "more meaningful input from members."

On other questions he stopped short of a commitment:

IssueWhat Van Hollen saidSpecific commitment?
Iran war fundingWould demand a vote cutting off money for offensive operationsYes
PrimariesWould recruit candidates but stay out of contested open primariesYes
FilibusterPersonally wants to end it, but the caucus has to discuss it firstNo
DSCC fundraisingWould not impose new rules "without consulting with the caucus"No
Medicare for AllSupports it but would not force a voteNo
Caucus inputWants power spread beyond the leaderNo details

What Happens Next in the Senate Leadership Race

Van Hollen said the caucus changed its rules after the last election so that no leadership vote could be held before December 1. He accused Schumer's team of trying to "short circuit that debate and again, move the date forward."

Some senators have already chosen sides. Bernie Sanders endorsed Van Hollen. Ruben Gallego, who said "When the manager takes you to the World Series, you give them another contract" and that it is "time to unify," sided with Schumer's side of the argument.

Sources