Fox Host Says John Thune Has 'Navel Gazing to Do' After SAVE Act Failure
The Fox fill-in host said voters "were pissed" the SAVE America Act didn't pass and asked whether Republicans are buying Thune's defense of the 60-vote rule.

Griff Jenkins, filling in on The Brian Kilmeade Show, said Monday that Senate Majority Leader John Thune has "navel gazing to do" after Thune defended the filibuster rule that kept the SAVE America Act from passing the Senate.
Jenkins, a Fox News correspondent and co-host of Fox & Friends Weekend, aired the Thune clip while discussing what he called "the blue tsunami, the Democrats sweep in the midterms." Six days earlier, Senate Republicans had reelected Thune as their leader even though the party lost its majority in the November 3 elections.
Jenkins Presses Thune on the SAVE Act
Jenkins said he found it "particularly interesting" to see Thune "trying to defend not passing the SAVE Act after it was quite apparent that voters, to be fair, were pissed. It didn't get done."
In the clip, Thune said Republicans "voted on it seven times" and "had 53 votes for photo ID, that narrow part of it. It takes 60 in the Senate." He continued: "This is the way the founders designed the Senate, to work exactly this way, to make it hard to do things." The legislative filibuster, he said, "protects minority rights and gives the minority in the country a voice in our government, which now we are going to appreciate because we're gonna be that minority."
"I mean, do you think the average Republican voter is buying that here after what we just saw happen?" Jenkins asked after the clip.
"I mean, do you think the average Republican voter is buying that here after what we just saw happen?" — Griff Jenkins on The Brian Kilmeade Show
Later in the segment, Jenkins said Thune has "quite a bit of navel gazing to do and looking in the mirror." He also questioned the strategy behind Trump's midterm rallies, which he said targeted "MAGA low propensity voters," adding that the numbers "are clearly showing that that was not a successful strategy."
What Happened to the SAVE America Act
The SAVE America Act passed the House. It would require voters to show photo identification at polling places and provide proof of citizenship when registering. In the Senate it fell short of the 60 votes needed to overcome a filibuster. During a rare weekend session on March 21, an amendment to the bill failed on a 49-41 vote, and the Deseret News reported that the measure was "on track to fail" because of opposition from Democrats and a handful of Republicans.
Jenkins's criticism echoes pressure Thune faced from the White House. In July, Trump wrote on Truth Social that "Thune should not allow the United States Senate to 'leave town' until it passes The Save America Act," KATV reported. Thune reportedly responded, according to KATV: "If somebody can show me how we get an outcome, how we get a result, how we get an answer to this, I'm all for it."
The rule Thune protected will soon shield his own conference. Ted Cruz has predicted that Senate Democrats will likely end the filibuster next year.
Thune Kept His Post After Midterm Losses
Senate Republicans reelected Thune by acclamation last Tuesday after losing at least seven seats, including seats in Ohio, North Carolina, South Carolina, Kansas and Texas, CBS News reported. Wisconsin Senator Ron Johnson pushed to delay the vote but said "this has never been anything against John Thune" and that Thune had been "very unfairly attacked by our base."
Before the election, Thune had defended the Senate GOP agenda against the charge that it had been too timid. "I don't know how you could be more aggressive," he said, according to CBS News.
The reelection has drawn criticism elsewhere on Fox. Jenkins's guest, a former senior Senate advisor and Trump appointee, objected to senators being reelected to leadership, and Sean Hannity said Senate Republicans should have held off on reelecting Thune.
What Voters Said in the Midterms
The AP Voter Poll found that about 4 in 10 voters named the economy as the top issue facing the country and roughly 3 in 10 named the state of democracy. About 1 in 10 each chose immigration or health care.
The GOP comes out of the election with poor numbers. In PolitiKool's polling average, 35.7 percent of Americans view the Republican Party favorably and 60.7 percent unfavorably, a net rating of −25.0.
What Comes Next
Republicans move into the minority in January with Thune still in charge, and the 60-vote rule he defended becomes the GOP's main defense against a Democratic agenda. Whether frustrated conservatives keep pressing Senate leaders, or turn their focus to the Democratic majority, is a question the conference has not yet had to answer.
Sources
- John Thune reelected Senate Republican leader (CBS News) — Thune reelected by acclamation on Nov. 10 after the GOP lost at least seven seats; quotes from Thune and Ron Johnson.
- Senate rejects proposals on transgender sports ban, TSA funding (Scripps News) — What the SAVE America Act requires: photo ID at the polls and proof of citizenship at registration.
- No men in women's sports amendment to SAVE America Act fails (Deseret News) — March 21 weekend vote of 49-41, short of 60; bill 'on track to fail.'
2 more sources
- Trump urges Thune to keep Senate in session, possibly end filibuster for SAVE America Act (KATV) — Trump's July 2026 push to end the filibuster and Thune's response.
- How America voted in the 2026 midterms: early takeaways from the AP Voter Poll — Top-issue shares: economy about 4 in 10, democracy about 3 in 10, immigration and health care about 1 in 10 each.