PolitiKool
Discourse from America’s online town square
Saturday, November 21, 2026

Jennifer Welch Disputes Democrats' Claim Kamala Harris Lost Over Culture Wars

A progressive podcaster says Kamala Harris ran on affordability and housing, and that Democrats keep borrowing Republican framing instead of going on offense.

Jennifer Welch
Illustration: PolitiKool (AI-assisted) (PolitiKool illustration)

Jennifer Welch, co-host of the I've Had It podcast, is rejecting the argument made by some Democrats that the party lost the 2024 election by focusing too much on social issues. She says that Kamala Harris campaigned on affordability and housing, and that it was Republicans who could not stop talking about trans people.

She made the remarks on a recent episode, after Democrats' midterm gains. Those gains have restarted a debate the party has been having since 2024: whether it should shy away from cultural fights or take them on directly.

What Jennifer Welch Said About the 2024 Post-Mortem

Welch reached the point after a segment on Jake Lang, a January 6 defendant pardoned by Donald Trump, who filmed himself confronting a Seattle cat adoption event and accusing it of sexualizing children, and a second on a Florida anti-DEI law that led Delray Beach to cancel its St. Patrick's Day parade. She then turned to her own party.

"After the 2024 election, I heard people within the Democratic Party say, we shouldn't have been so focused on social issues and culture wars. And I was like, I don't see the left, I didn't see Kamala's campaign as focused on that," Welch said. "I heard her talking about affordability, housing, blah, blah. On the right, I hear them talking about this all the time."

She said Democrats should stop adopting the right's framing. "We need to play offense on this stuff," she said, adding: "Why is MAGA constantly talking about trans people?" She also questioned how the right's focus helps voters. "Focused on DEI, how does that lower your gas prices?" she asked.

What the 2024 Ad Record Shows

The record partly supports her. Harris's economic agenda called for 3 million new homes, up to $25,000 in down-payment help for people who have paid their rent on time for two years, and a federal ban on grocery price gouging, CBS News reported. The Wesleyan Media Project found that both campaigns' ads focused mostly on "bread-and-butter issues like the economy and taxes." Pro-Harris ads also gave some attention to abortion rights, and pro-Trump ads spent a stretch on transgender policy.

That stretch was expensive. As of Oct. 9, 2024, the Trump campaign and Republican groups had spent more than $21 million on anti-trans and anti-LGBTQ TV ads, nearly a third of their roughly $66 million in TV spending over that period, AdImpact told ABC News. By the time of NBC News' November 2024 reporting, Republicans had spent more than $200 million that year on network TV ads about transgender issues, according to AdImpact data reported by NBC News.

Democrats Who Blamed Social Issues

The Democrats Welch was answering do exist, though she did not name any of them. After the 2024 election, Massachusetts Representative Seth Moulton told The New York Times that "Democrats spend way too much time trying not to offend anyone." New York Representative Tom Suozzi said the party had to "stop pandering to the far left," NBC News reported.

Welch also said trans people make up "less than 1% of the population." That is close to the record. The Williams Institute at UCLA estimated in August 2025 that 0.8 percent of U.S. adults, about 2.1 million people, identify as transgender. The figure is 1 percent when people aged 13 and older are counted.

Voters Rank Cost of Living Far Above Trans Issues

Polling taken before the midterms supports her broader point about voters' priorities. In an AP-NORC poll released Oct. 15, 85 percent of respondents called the economy one of the most significant issues in weighing their vote, and 35 percent called artificial intelligence a substantial issue. Transgender issues ranked significantly lower, at 12 percent.

Welch said culture-war attacks are all Republicans have left. "The culture wars ... is all the Republican Party has, they've run out of scapegoats," she said, arguing the party has "no real policy and no real agenda to deliver for the American people materially."

At least one prominent Republican has said something similar. At a Nov. 4 press conference in Tallahassee, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis called the midterms "close to an extinction-level event" for his party. He said of the GOP's anti-trans ads, "That was not the issue motivating voters," The Advocate reported.

What Happens Next

Welch does not expect Republicans to change course. "They will not stop. I mean, the fascist project will always rely upon scapegoating people," she said.

Democrats made gains in places like Mississippi, where a Democratic district attorney is projected to unseat Cindy Hyde-Smith, though the margin could still change before certification. PolitiKool's final pre-election generic ballot polling average, as of Nov. 3, had Democrats ahead by 8.9 points. Still, the midterms did not settle whether Democrats should avoid cultural fights or go after Republicans on them, as Welch wants.

Sources

5 more sources