PolitiKool
Discourse from America’s online town square
Saturday, November 21, 2026

Joy Reid Says Democrats Are 'Doing Politics' Against Donald Trump's 'Fascism'

Two weeks after the party won both chambers, Reid said 60-vote excuses and 'minimalist' bills will not meet the moment, but she still sees elections as the way out.

Joy Reid, Donald Trump
Illustration: PolitiKool (AI-assisted) (PolitiKool illustration)

Joy Reid, the former MSNBC host who now hosts The Joy Reid Show, said on Monday that Democrats' new congressional majorities will not be enough if the party governs by Senate procedure. President Donald Trump's administration, she said, is "doing fascism and Democrats are doing politics."

The remarks came two weeks after Democrats won the House and Senate in the Nov. 3 midterm elections. Reid made her case after airing congressional testimony about Renee Good and Alex Pretti, two people killed by federal immigration agents in Minneapolis in January.

"They're doing fascism and Democrats are doing politics and it's very disturbing and it's very concerning because I think you can't beat fascism with politics," Reid said.

Joy Reid Faults Democrats' Incrementalism

"The deaths are not minimalistic. The deaths are not minor, they're not minimal, and they're not being operated minimally," she said. "The Trump regime are maximalists, not minimalists."

She said Democrats are doing "the Schoolhouse Rock version of governing." The party, she said, has "proven to be rather slow and, you know, sometimes very gentle in the way that they exercise power."

"And you can't exercise power in a gentle way when the people you're dealing with are actual fascists," Reid said. She held up Michigan Democrat Abdul El-Sayed's health care pitch as a model, describing it as passing Medicare for All and daring Trump not to sign it.

Reid Still Sees Elections as the Way Out

Reid did not write off the ballot box. "Like you can ultimately, you can with elections," she said, pointing to Brazil, Hungary and Poland. "I think Poland took about eight years," she added. In Hungary, Prime Minister Viktor Orbán conceded defeat to Péter Magyar's Tisza party, ending 16 years in power.

Her argument was that winning is only the first step. "We just had an election. And once you have an election, you actually have to dismantle fascism," she said. "So we just had our Poland moment, our Brazil moment." In Brazil, she said, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva still has to undo "Bolsonaro's structures and Bolsonaro's institutional destruction."

Democrats' Senate Majority Falls Short of 60

The 60-vote threshold Reid dismissed is still out of the party's reach. Even if Mary Peltola wins Alaska, where ranked-choice tabulation is set for Wednesday, she would be "the 56th member of the new Democratic majority," the Anchorage Daily News reported.

Rep. Gwen Moore, a Wisconsin Democrat who appeared earlier in the episode, said "those 56 senators" would put "a lot of pressure on four or five Republicans." On the same episode, guests Rashad Robinson and Jennifer Welch criticized Chuck Schumer's leadership, and the show featured Sen. Chris Van Hollen's challenge to Schumer for the party's top Senate post.

What ICE's Own Records Show

Reid said of the people killed by immigration agents, "We're talking about like two dozen people." She did not say how she arrived at that number. Fatal shootings during street operations are counted separately from deaths in detention.

Custody deaths have risen sharply. ICE's detainee death reporting page lists 36 deaths in fiscal 2026, a partial-year count covering October 2025 through Aug. 23, 2026. That is the most of any year on the page, whose records begin in fiscal 2018. The page lists 21 deaths in fiscal 2020, during Trump's first term, and three in fiscal 2022 under President Joe Biden.

Reid showed a chart of custody deaths and said, "The spikes are Donald Trump's first regime, Donald Trump's second regime, and George W. Bush's regime."

Stephen Miller and the ICE Question

The segment also focused on Stephen Miller, the architect of Trump's deportation program. Trump announced on Nov. 6 that Miller would replace Susie Wiles as White House chief of staff, CBS News reported. In response, Schumer called Miller "the architect of the most barbaric, inhumane policies of this administration." House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries said Miller has "American blood on his hands."

Reid's guest, Jean Guerrero, the author of Hatemonger, a book about Miller, pressed Democrats to scrap the agency. "So they need to abolish ICE," Guerrero said. She said leaving the agency in place would be "the biggest mistake they could possibly make."

Reid shared the view that the agency has no place. She said ICE agents "are masked and they are unleashed and they do not need to exist," adding, "ICE never existed. It didn't exist until 9/11." She did not frame that as a legislative demand, and she left Democrats with a question their leaders have not yet answered: what a majority will do with power it cannot fully use.

Sources

1 more source