Joy Reid Makes the Case for Chris Van Hollen to Replace Chuck Schumer as Leader
She says it would take just 29 votes on a secret ballot, and that Schumer should get no credit for wins in races his team backed little or late.

Former MSNBC host Joy Reid used a live Tuesday episode of The Joy Reid Show to make the case that Senate Democrats should replace Chuck Schumer with Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen as majority leader. She told viewers the job is within reach of a small group of senators.
"You need 29 United States senators to vote for Chris Van Hollen, and you will have Chris Van Hollen as your majority leader in the Senate," Reid said.
Reid did not formally endorse Van Hollen. But she spent much of the Senate segment making the case against Schumer. She said the New York Democrat and his allies gave Senate candidates in Florida, Louisiana, Kentucky, Mississippi and Maine little or no money, or money only at the end. She also said the party's midterm gains belonged to activists, not to its leaders. Her remarks follow Bernie Sanders' statement this week that he will not back Schumer for leader.
Joy Reid Says Chuck Schumer Should Not Get Credit for the Sweep
"And while people in the Democratic leadership world are trying to give him and his other leaders team credit for the big Senate sweep, they don't get that credit," Reid said. "This was not the Democratic Party winning this massive race."
Reid said Florida's Angie Nixon got about $5,000 from Schumer's leadership PAC late in the race. She said Louisiana's Jamie Davis "came within 25,000 votes" and added: "They gave him like exactly nothing." In Kentucky, she said, the party "gave no money at all." PolitiKool has not confirmed the Louisiana margin or the spending claims for Louisiana and Kentucky. Reid also said party leaders "threw tiny bits of money at Scott Colom" in Mississippi "at the very end." She said the deadline for curing ballots there had passed on Tuesday and that the race "should be called tomorrow."
Colom has his own complaint about the party's leaders. "It's not a good thing that both Leader Schumer and Leader Jeffries both live in the same borough, right?" he said in a clip Reid played.
Reid also said she had heard from people on the ground about "the defunding of the candidate in Maine that he didn't have the support of the DSCC because he would not commit to voting for Schumer." She offered no documents for that claim.
She blamed the Cook Political Report for steering donors away from these candidates. "Cook Political Report decides by itself with an unknown algorithm who's viable and who is not," Reid said.
What the Spending Record Shows
In Florida and Maine, the record backs part of what Reid said and cuts against other parts.
In Florida, the DSCC did not donate to Nixon's campaign, Atlanta Black Star reported. The same report said Schumer hosted a virtual fundraiser for her and gave through his PAC. The exact $5,000 figure is Reid's. Nixon lost to Senator Ashley Moody by about 3 points. PolitiKool's polling average had Moody ahead by 6.3 points.
Maine is the hardest of Reid's claims to square with the record. Troy Jackson, the former logger who unseated Senator Susan Collins, drew Senate Majority PAC money: in October the super PAC said it would spend $3 million more in Maine to beat Collins and help Jackson. The DSCC also set up a fund after Graham Platner, who had been the Democratic nominee in Maine, left the race. That fund would transfer to Jackson, the Bangor Daily News reported in July. It is unclear how much it raised.
How the Senate Democratic Leadership Vote Works
Senate Democrats pick their leader by secret ballot, and a simple majority of the caucus wins. Incoming senators vote before they are sworn in, and the vote is expected in December, Scripps News reported. Reid's figure of 29 assumes a 56-member caucus, the most seats Democrats could hold.
Reid noted that Van Hollen "has been saying no, no, no" to being nominated for majority leader. In a clip she aired, he said "we shouldn't have a coronation" and that he was "in active listening mode." Asked whether he was open to running, he answered: "I haven't closed the door."
Van Hollen has also accused Schumer and the DSCC of siding "with the crypto industry and AIPAC" against some candidates in primaries, Roll Call reported. Schumer has said he is confident he will be elected majority leader.
What Happens Next
Reid's call to viewers was conditional: if they want a change, she said, "there needs to be some whip counting happening." Schumer's critics have no declared candidate yet. Michigan Senator Elissa Slotkin is withholding support until she sees a concrete plan, is not actively seeking the job and has not endorsed anyone, Roll Call reported.
Sources
- Van Hollen considers challenge to Schumer for Senate Democratic leader — Secret ballot, simple majority, December timing, incoming senators vote, Democrats could hold up to 56 seats
- Rift grows among Senate Democrats over who will lead in majority — Van Hollen's 'crypto industry and AIPAC' criticism of Schumer and the DSCC; Slotkin withholding support until she sees a concrete plan, not actively seeking the job, no endorsement; Sanders' statement
- Chuck Schumer Faces Claims He Left Angie Nixon Behind — DSCC gave Nixon nothing; Schumer fundraiser and PAC contribution; roughly 3-point loss
2 more sources
- Top Democratic super PAC spends more in Michigan, Maine — October 14, 2026: Senate Majority PAC said it would spend $3 million more in Maine to beat Collins and help Troy Jackson
- National Democrats rally behind Troy Jackson fundraising — July 2026: DSCC fund set up after previous nominee Graham Platner's exit would transfer to Jackson; amount raised unclear