PolitiKool
Discourse from America’s online town square
Saturday, November 21, 2026

Megyn Kelly Calls Thomas Massie's Pete Hegseth Impeachment Push 'Dumb'

She said the outgoing Republican is doing the Democrats' work for them, and that Pete Hegseth acted at Donald Trump's request.

Megyn Kelly, Thomas Massie, Pete Hegseth
Illustration: PolitiKool (AI-assisted) (PolitiKool illustration)

Megyn Kelly said on Tuesday that Republican Representative Thomas Massie's eight articles of impeachment against Secretary of War Pete Hegseth are a political mistake. She argued that the effort will rally a Trump base that is already angry with the president, and that it blames Hegseth for decisions Donald Trump made.

"I think this is very dumb politically like this is it's Massie it's not a Democrat I think it's dumb for Massie," Kelly said on The Megyn Kelly Show, speaking with journalist Matt Taibbi.

Her objection was to the politics of the move. She did not defend Hegseth on the merits. She acknowledged that some Republican senators may be uneasy about "some of those not entirely kosher actions by the Department of War."

What Massie's Articles of Impeachment Allege

Massie, a Kentucky Republican, first read the articles on the House floor on September 15. Fox News reported that the eight articles accuse Hegseth of waging the Iran war in violation of the War Powers Resolution of 1973, disregarding House and Senate directives to withdraw troops, and keeping up hostilities past the law's 60-day limit. The other articles accuse him of failing to minimize civilian casualties, of extrajudicial killings in the Caribbean boat strikes, of retaliating against Democratic Senator Mark Kelly of Arizona over a video urging service members to refuse illegal orders, of the "Kidnapping of a Sovereign Foreign Leader" in the capture of Nicolás Maduro, and of launching an unauthorized operation in Yemen.

After Massie first read the articles, House Republican leaders recessed the chamber early, delaying a vote. Massie reintroduced updated articles on Monday, which restarted a two-day clock for a House vote. Donald Trump has said he would "stand by" Hegseth even if the House impeaches him.

Kelly said that legal analyst Jonathan Turley "doesn't think much of six of them but two of them he thinks may have some legs." Taibbi said those two are the boat strikes and the article concerning Mark Kelly.

Why Megyn Kelly Says the Move Backfires

Kelly noted that Massie lost his seat. He was defeated in May by Ed Gallrein, a Trump-endorsed former Navy SEAL. Kelly said that "he's bitter because he got primaried by a Trump candidate and lost." She also credited him with being right about the Epstein files and the Iran war.

"Why not let the Democrats just come in and do what they're gonna do why take this on as an outgoing Republican congressman," Kelly asked. "I think it makes you look petty it will I think have the effect of rallying the Trump base to some extent that's kind of mad at Trump right now but they're not gonna like this."

She also argued that Hegseth is the wrong target: "whatever Pete's done he's done at the request of Trump." She compared the effort to the House Republican impeachment of Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, which she described as "engaging in a fiction." House Republicans impeached Mayorkas over his handling of the southern border in February 2024, and the Democratic-led Senate dismissed both articles that April on a party-line vote.

Hegseth called the effort "a political spectacle a personal manifesto driven by ego and resentment" at a news conference on Tuesday. "It's a farce and it's a stunt and everybody knows it," he said.

Ted Cruz Predicts Hegseth Is Out

Kelly played a clip of Texas Republican Senator Ted Cruz speaking on his own podcast, Verdict with Ted Cruz, on Monday. Cruz predicted that "either he will resign voluntarily or Trump will fire him or if that does not happen I think it is extremely likely if not certain that the house will impeach him."

Cruz's argument rested on timing. Republicans hold the Senate until January, so a replacement nominated during the lame-duck session could still be confirmed by them. "If he resigns or is fired next year we can't confirm a replacement," he said.

The Senate Math

A simple House majority can impeach, but conviction requires two-thirds of senators present. That is 67 votes if all 100 senators vote. Kelly put the number at 66 and said "they're not gonna have that." Democrats will hold at least 54 seats in the new Senate, with races in Alaska and Mississippi still uncalled. With 54 Democratic votes, a conviction would need 13 Republicans.

Taibbi said he was "torn" on the effort. He noted that presidents of both parties have ordered military strikes without congressional approval, and that "nobody ever said a thing before when it was Biden or Obama or Bush or Clinton or Reagan."

The Iran war has already cost Republicans politically. It figured heavily in the party's midterm losses a week ago, and Trump's approval stands at 38.1 percent in PolitiKool's polling average. Whether House Republican leaders can block a vote this week, or whether Hegseth leaves first, as Cruz predicted, is still unresolved.

Sources

3 more sources