Elissa Slotkin Wants Israel to 'Graduate' From Financial Dependence on U.S.
The Michigan senator, who once opposed limits on arms to Israel, says what changed her vote was the 'weaponizing of humanitarian aid.'

Senator Elissa Slotkin, a Michigan Democrat, told former Obama speechwriter Jon Lovett that the United States should move its relationship with Israel off a "model of financial dependence" on American taxpayers. She called the change a "right-sizing" of the alliance, not a cutoff of aid.
The Pod Save America interview was recorded at Crooked Con and released on Tuesday, a week after Democrats' midterm sweep. It also came a week after President Donald Trump said U.S. aid to Israel would end, which Slotkin cited as evidence that the relationship is already shifting.
What Elissa Slotkin Said About Israel Aid
Lovett asked Slotkin why her vote had changed. "The previous April, you had been a no. So, I'm curious what changed for you," he said.
Slotkin said that "the resetting of the relationship is happening in real time" and that there is "a real conversation" about where it goes next.
"How do we graduate from this model of financial dependence of U.S. taxpayer dollars funding huge portions of their defense budget?" she asked. "How do we change that to right-size it for a very different moment in our history and a very different moment in their history?"
She said her vote turned on Gaza. What was different, she said, was "the literally weaponizing of humanitarian aid." Slotkin, a former CIA analyst who served three tours in Iraq, said, "I understand what is a violation of the law of war," and added: "So that to me kind of broke me. And that's why I voted the way I did and have since then."
She also said Democrats must take Jewish voters' fears of antisemitism seriously, and "we need to be able to have an honest conversation about the behavior of Bibi Netanyahu and the military in Gaza. You can have those two separate conversations."
Donald Trump's Netanyahu Claim, Checked
Slotkin pointed to Trump's own words, paraphrasing him as saying, "Bibi Netanyahu asked me to not send more money," an amount she put at "over $3 billion."
Trump's actual remarks, made in a Fox News phone interview on Election Day, Nov. 3, were close but not identical. Slotkin dated them to the day before the election. "I was approached by Bibi Netanyahu, and we've been talking about it for a couple of years because it's a lot of money," he said, adding that Israel gets "$4 billion of things and money, and they don't need it," PBS NewsHour reported. Netanyahu's office did not immediately comment. Israeli Finance Ministry officials expressed surprise, though Netanyahu has publicly called for phasing out U.S. aid in favor of joint investments, ABC News reported. The cutoff has already drawn criticism on the right, including from Fox News' Brian Kilmeade.
Slotkin's "over $3 billion" holds up. The 2016 memorandum of understanding commits $38 billion in military aid from fiscal 2019 through 2028, $33 billion of it in Foreign Military Financing grants and $5 billion for missile defense, according to the Congressional Research Service. That works out to roughly $3.8 billion a year.
Elissa Slotkin's Senate Vote Switch
On April 15, the Senate rejected two resolutions from Vermont independent Senator Bernie Sanders to block arms sales to Israel. The measures covered military bulldozers and 1,000-pound bombs. Forty Democrats voted against the bulldozer sale and 36 against the bomb sale, Jewish Insider reported. Slotkin voted yes on both after opposing similar efforts before. She said she would keep supporting missile-defense systems.
Support has climbed quickly. Only 15 senators backed similar measures in April 2025, NOTUS reported, and 27 Democrats backed at least one in July 2025. Only seven Democrats, including Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, opposed both resolutions in April.
Other speakers at Crooked Con went further than Slotkin. Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen said, "my view is we should end the open American taxpayer checkbook to the government of Israel," and he urged colleagues to remove defense bill provisions that he said would "permanently couple U.S. defense production to the government of Israel." Melat Kiros, a Colorado Democrat elected to the House on Nov. 3, said, "I wanna see us ending military sales to Israel."
How Democratic Voters Have Shifted on Israel
Slotkin's position follows a shift among the party's voters. Gallup's World Affairs survey, conducted February 2–16, found:
- 65 percent of Democrats sympathize more with the Palestinians, and 17 percent more with the Israelis.
- Among all U.S. adults, 41 percent side more with the Palestinians and 36 percent with the Israelis, a gap Gallup called not statistically significant.
- A year earlier, Israelis led among all adults, 46 percent to 33 percent.
What Happens Next
The current memorandum runs through fiscal 2028, and Congress effectively wrote its funding levels into law, so Trump has not explained how the aid would stop. A new agreement is reportedly being negotiated, the Congressional Research Service noted in June.
Slotkin, who told Lovett she is "not ruling anything out" on a bid for majority leader, did not say how much aid she would cut or how fast. On Israel, her answer was about direction: Democrats "need to use that leverage appropriately."
Sources
- Jewish Insider: Following Bernie Sanders' lead, 40 Senate Democrats vote against arms sales to Israel — Slotkin's switch from prior opposition, 40 Democrats against the bulldozer sale and 36 against the bomb sale, her support for missile-defense systems, the seven Democratic holdouts, and July 2025 comparison
- NOTUS: More Senate Democrats are breaking with Israel — Only 15 senators backed similar measures in April 2025
- Gallup: Israelis No Longer Ahead in Americans' Middle East Sympathies — February 2026 sympathies among Democrats and all adults, and the year-earlier comparison among all adults
4 more sources
- PBS NewsHour: Trump says U.S. will stop giving $4 billion in aid to Israel next year — Trump's verbatim Nov. 3 remarks that Netanyahu approached him
- ABC News: Trump says $4 billion in Israel military aid will end this year — MOU terms, Israeli Finance Ministry surprise, Netanyahu's prior calls to phase out aid
- CRS: U.S. Foreign Aid to Israel (RL33222) — $38 billion FY2019–2028 MOU breakdown
- CRS: Possible Changes in U.S. Military Aid to Israel (IN12695) — Reported negotiation of a new MOU, June 2026