PolitiKool
Discourse from America’s online town square
Saturday, November 21, 2026

John Fetterman Presses Democrats to Aim Their Anger at Iran, Not at Israel

Asked whether anything would make him walk away from his party, the Pennsylvania senator pointed to a Maryland senator's challenge to Chuck Schumer for Democratic leader.

John Fetterman
Illustration: PolitiKool (AI-assisted) (PolitiKool illustration)

Senator John Fetterman said in an interview that Democrats in both the House and the Senate reach first to punish Israel and withhold aid, and he asked why his party does not aim that anger at Iran instead.

The Pennsylvania Democrat made the remarks after being asked whether there was a red line that would make him walk away from the party if it moved far to the left. He answered, "Yeah, absolutely," and then named Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen, who is challenging Chuck Schumer for majority leader ahead of a caucus vote in December.

"It would be troubling if my caucus elects someone like Van Hollen that has really made his name being very anti hostile to Israel," Fetterman said.

He did not say outright that he would leave the party if Van Hollen won.

What John Fetterman Said About Iran and Israel

Fetterman said Democrats should direct their anger toward Iran and the groups it backs. "If you are going to be angry or hostile towards any countries in the region why not make that you know Iran or Hezbollah or Hamas," he said.

He described the instinct to punish Israel as a habit of both chambers. "Both in the house now in the Senate know their first instincts are to punish Israel and to withhold these kinds of aid," Fetterman said. "Why isn't your first [instinct] to say let's hold Iran accountable."

That is Fetterman's own description of his party. He did not name a specific vote or bill.

How Senate Democrats Have Voted on Israel Arms Sales

The clearest test in the Senate has been a series of joint resolutions from Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders to block specific arms sales to Israel. Every one has failed, but the number of senators voting for them has grown.

On April 3, 2025, two Sanders resolutions each drew 15 votes, failing 15-82 and 15-83, according to the Congressional Record.

The biggest shift came on April 15, 2026. A resolution to block a sale of bulldozers failed 40-59, and a second, on a sale of bombs, failed 36-63, according to the Senate roll calls.

Only seven Democrats voted against the bulldozer resolution: Fetterman, Schumer, Richard Blumenthal, Chris Coons, Catherine Cortez Masto, Kirsten Gillibrand and Jacky Rosen, the roll call shows. Four more Democrats, Gary Peters, Jack Reed, Mark Warner and Sheldon Whitehouse, joined them in opposing the bomb resolution, according to that vote's roll call.

Selected Senate votes on Sanders resolutions to block Israel arms sales
Apr 2025 (S.J.Res. 33)
15votes
Apr 2025 (S.J.Res. 26)
15votes
Apr 2026 bulldozers
40votes
Apr 2026 bombs
36votes

Total senators voting yes on four selected Sanders resolutions; every one failed. Sources by figure: April 2025 votes, Congressional Record (govinfo); April 2026 bulldozer and bomb votes, Senate roll calls via Voteview.

Source: Congressional Record (April 2025 votes); Voteview Senate roll calls (April 2026 votes)

Fetterman spoke of both chambers and of aid generally, and the Senate record covers only arms sales. Those totals suggest that a majority of Senate Democrats has now voted to block at least one sale: the bulldozer resolution drew 40 votes, and only seven Democrats opposed it. The shift is recent, though. A year before the April 2026 votes, only 15 senators backed each of the two resolutions, according to the Congressional Record.

Offensive Weapons Versus Defensive Aid

Fetterman's phrase "these kinds of aid" does not say what kind he means. The April 2026 Senate resolutions targeted two specific sales: bulldozers and bombs.

Van Hollen has drawn a line between offensive weapons and defensive aid himself. He has said he opposes offensive weapons sales "so long as Israel is violating international law and American law" but supports selling Iron Dome components, the Jewish Telegraphic Agency reported. He has consistently voted to block arms transfers to Israel, and he voted for the bomb resolution in April 2026, the roll call shows.

Michigan Senator Elissa Slotkin still backs missile-defense systems for Israel, but on April 15, 2026, she voted yes on both the bulldozer and bomb resolutions, the Senate roll calls show. In remarks PolitiKool covered, she said, "I understand what is a violation of the law of war," and added, "So that to me kind of broke me." She has also criticized what she called "the literally weaponizing of humanitarian aid."

What Happens Next

Senate Democrats will pick their leader in December. Sanders and Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed have backed Van Hollen, while Schumer has said he is "confident" he will win, the Jewish Telegraphic Agency reported. Sanders has already said he will not back Schumer.

Schumer voted against both Sanders resolutions on April 15, 2026, as Fetterman did. Fetterman did not say what he would do if the caucus chose Van Hollen.

"It would be troubling," he said.

Sources

1 more source